Do you know what…?
Why did traders pay others to take over their oil futures in April 2020?

AI-generated image, not a photograph. This edition's article, audio and test are AI-generated and published automatically without prior human review. Sources · Editorial & AI Policy
Listen to today’s article
On April 20, 2020, the May NYMEX West Texas Intermediate (WTI) oil futures contract settled at minus $37.63 per barrel, the day before expiration. Some holders were paying others to take over their positions. Pandemic restrictions and the economic slowdown had slashed oil consumption, sending surplus crude into storage. But this was not simply a verdict on oil's usefulness. Holders carrying positions through expiration had to make or take physical delivery at Cushing, Oklahoma, unless they had arranged otherwise. Traders normally avoided that obligation by offsetting their positions beforehand; those still seeking an exit were .
The apparent paradox was inside the tanks. According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA), Cushing's storage was approximately 76% full on April 17, 2020—not a measurement at the instant prices turned negative. Empty space could already be leased or committed: access was arrangements, not merely physical room. EIA identified scarce, expensive available storage and difficulty finding buyers as reasons for negative sales. Paying a counterparty was tantamount to buying an escape from a delivery obligation. Another revealing detail: EIA said only about 1% of traded futures went to physical delivery. An uncommon outcome could nevertheless become decisive as expiration approached.
The settlement was at odds with the familiar assumption that a valuable commodity must always command a positive price. Yet longer-dated WTI contracts remained positive: this was not a universal price for oil. Nor was accepting a negative-priced position free money; the recipient assumed obligations and potential costs. The storage-and-expiration mechanism explains why an exit could become expensive, without establishing every trading strategy's contribution to the collapse. The enduring lesson for anyone reading a market quotation is practical: ask what must be delivered, where and when. Physical room and commercially available capacity are not —and a financial contract cannot make that distinction disappear.
Sources (3)
- U.S. Energy Information Administration — historical explanation of negative WTI futures prices, April 27, 2020
- Commodity Futures Trading Commission — release announcing the interim WTI trading report, November 23, 2020
- Commodity Futures Trading Commission — Commissioner Dan Berkovitz's statement on the interim report, November 23, 2020
